
There have been four previous MCLA Division I finals that were settled by one goal, including a 16-15 overtime win for Cal over BYU in 1998, but this year’s clash between Michigan and Chapman was the best – and most important – in MCLA history for three reasons.

Even the usually stoic John Paul, Michigan's head coach, could not contain a smile after the Big Blue won its second straight MCLA championship on Saturday. He should be happy, especially since he and his team were part of the most important title game in the association's history. Ryan McKee
First, this one was televised live on a nationwide cable channel (Fox College Sports) and available streaming live on the web. From what I was told, this did not come cheap – $50,000 was the number thrown at me from a reliable source – but considering the product they manage to televise, I would deem it worth the expense. The risk was high: if the game turned into a dog along the lines of the Michigan contests against Sonoma or Colorado, airing the game might have caused more harm than good. The quality of this contest made for a big pay-off.
Second, it showed that the MCLA was not turning into a one-team league. It’s always nice to have a signature program to sell a league, but the association needs excitement now, not inevitability. As someone who covers NCAA Division III, I respect what Jim Berkman did with his Salisbury program for the past decade, but it makes for a boring spring when the outcome is essentially predetermined. While Michigan earned its just desserts, Chapman’s ability to compete well with the Wolverines keeps open the hope that UM won’t run away from the pack in the future. If one assumes comparative scores hold great significance, we can even consider Colorado State, BYU and Simon Fraser as programs at the same level.
With that being said, there is an obvious gap between the haves and have-nots in the MCLA in both divisions. It’s something that will have to be addressed sooner or later, likely in a form of a definitive set of standards for inclusion in each division to ensure everyone is operating on a near-level playing field in terms of resources and competitiveness.
Third, this game was the last confirmation that the selection committee in its inaugural season got it right. With the exception of No. 10 Florida State beating No. 7 Cal Poly in the first round of the D-I tourney, every other game where the seeding didn’t hold involved two teams ranked one seed apart – two #8-#9 upsets, one #5-#4 and one #2-#1. That’s pretty darn good for your first go around with the committee structure. There were 10 total one-goal games, but that’s more of a testament to the parity within the MCLA than any ranking malfunction.
There was a lot more riding on this game than just crowing a national champion, and pretty much all the way around, the MCLA came up aces.



High School Boys

